In a fast-paced, modern world dominated by rapid digital consumption and the rise of social media platforms, the traditional book review might seem like a relic of the past. Yet, as we navigate the literary landscape of 2025, the question remains: Are book reviews still relevant? The answer, nuanced and multifaceted, is a resounding yes — but with important caveats. Book reviews continue to hold significant cultural and intellectual value, but they need to adapt and coexist with newer mediums such as BookTok and other social media-driven literary communities.
The Enduring Value of Book Reviews
Book reviews have long been a cornerstone of literary culture. For years, they have provided readers with critical insights, contextual analysis, and thoughtful engagement with texts. Reviews serve as a bridge between the author’s work and the reader’s understanding, offering a lens through which to interpret complex themes, narrative structures, and stylistic choices.
In 2025, this role remains vital. Despite the proliferation of instant opinions and bite-sized content, in-depth reviews offer a level of rigor and expertise that is difficult to replicate in short-form social media posts. They encourage readers to slow down, reflect, and engage critically with literature, fostering a deeper appreciation that transcends mere entertainment.
Moreover, book reviews contribute to the literary ecosystem by shaping publishing trends, influencing awards, and guiding libraries and educators in their selections. They act as gatekeepers and tastemakers, helping to elevate voices that might otherwise be overlooked in a saturated market.
The Rise of New Media: BookTok and Beyond
However, the landscape of literary criticism has undeniably shifted. Platforms like TikTok’s BookTok community have revolutionised how readers discover and discuss books. With millions of users sharing enthusiastic, often highly personal recommendations, BookTok has become a powerful force in driving book sales and shaping popular taste.
Unlike traditional reviews, BookTok content is typically informal, emotive, and visually engaging. It thrives on immediacy and relatability, often focusing on personal connection rather than critical analysis. This democratisation of literary discourse has opened doors for diverse voices and fostered vibrant communities around genres like YA, fantasy, and romance. It’s also made reading relatable, accessible and more appealing for a predominantly young audience.
Yet, this new medium is not without its limitations. The brevity and performative nature of social media can sometimes reduce complex works to catchy soundbites or viral trends, potentially oversimplifying nuanced narratives. Additionally, the commercial influence of viral success can skew attention toward certain titles, sidelining less marketable but equally deserving works, perpetuating a culture where voices are marginalised and sidelined.
Tradition Meets Innovation
Rather than viewing traditional book reviews and social media literary content as competing forces, it is more productive to see them as complementary. Each serves different reader needs and preferences, and together they enrich the literary conversation.
Traditional reviews provide depth, context, and critical frameworks that help readers navigate the complexities of literature. Social media platforms offer immediacy, accessibility, and community engagement, making reading a shared, dynamic experience.
Publishers and authors increasingly recognize this synergy. Many now leverage BookTok buzz to amplify critical acclaim, while reviewers incorporate social media trends to stay relevant and reach broader audiences. Hybrid models are emerging, such as long-form reviews published online with embedded video reactions or interactive discussions.
Challenges and Opportunities Ahead
The coexistence of traditional and new media also raises important questions about authority, expertise, and inclusivity in literary criticism. Who gets to be a reviewer? What standards should apply? How can the literary world balance professional critique with grassroots enthusiasm?
In 2025, the answer lies in embracing plurality. Book reviews remain essential for their analytical rigor and cultural stewardship, but they must evolve to engage with diverse voices and formats. Meanwhile, social media’s role in democratising literary discourse should be celebrated, even as we remain mindful of its pitfalls.
Conclusion
Book reviews are far from obsolete. They continue to play a crucial role in shaping literary culture, guiding readers, and fostering critical engagement. Yet, their relevance in 2025 is enhanced, not diminished, by the rise of new media like BookTok.
The future of literary criticism is hybrid, inclusive, and dynamic — a space where traditional expertise and passionate community voices coexist and enrich one another. For readers, this means more ways than ever to discover, discuss, and delight in books. For literature itself, it means a vibrant, evolving conversation that honors both the past and the present.
Words by Sophia McHardy
Support The Indiependent
We’re trying to raise £200 a month to help cover our operational costs. This includes our ‘Writer of the Month’ awards, where we recognise the amazing work produced by our contributor team. If you’ve enjoyed reading our site, we’d really appreciate it if you could donate to The Indiependent. Whether you can give £1 or £10, you’d be making a huge difference to our small team.